Learning From Experience: Why I Prefer Students with a Test Under Their Belt

Standardized tests like the ACT, SAT, and PSAT have become rites of passage for high school students aspiring for college admission. Often, parents and students focus intently on the score from the first attempt. But there’s immense value in having a prior test experience, primarily because it provides a benchmark for growth. Let’s delve deeper into why having an initial test score can shape a clearer, more realistic understanding of a student’s capabilities.

1. Establishing a Benchmark

A student’s first attempt at a standardized test is less about the score they achieve and more about establishing a starting point. Without this initial score, it’s challenging to measure progress. The score offers a concrete number, a benchmark, from which improvements can be measured. This benchmark helps me, as a college entrance exam coach, guide students and parents alike to set realistic expectations for future attempts.

2. The Illusion of Preparedness

Parents and students often approach standardized tests with a degree of confidence. They operate under the belief that the student’s existing knowledge from school will suffice. More often than not, this can lead to overestimations about performance potential. However, when confronted with the real test environment – the ticking clock, the silence of the examination room, and the pressure of the stakes involved – the performance can greatly differ from the expectation. Without a tangible benchmark, parents and students might have misconceptions about the student’s natural testing abilities. The initial test score provides an objective measure, helping dispel any myths and set the stage for informed discussions on improvement strategies.

3. Understanding the Test Environment

Having an official test under their belt provides students with invaluable experience. They get a feel for the actual testing environment, the format of the questions, the pressure of the timer, and the endurance required to sit through the entire test. This experience is irreplaceable and gives students a clearer understanding of the test’s format, the environment, and the psychological challenges they might face, like anxiety or time management issues. This exposure prepares them for future attempts, reducing test-day jitters.

4. Feedback Loop Creation

An initial test score, combined with detailed feedback on each section, creates a feedback loop. This loop informs students of the areas they need to focus on and helps me tailor my teaching strategies to address specific gaps more effectively. With an actual test score in hand, I can identify specific areas of improvement and craft a study plan that directly addresses those weaknesses.

5. Validating the Preparation Process

When students come to me after their initial test, we have a clear roadmap to start their preparation. This first score helps us both see the journey ahead and understand the steps we need to take. This transparency ensures we’re on the same page and fosters trust in the preparation process.


Encouraging your child to take the ACT or SAT before seeking tutoring isn’t about setting them up for failure; it’s about grounding their preparation in reality. The value of an initial standardized test score goes beyond the number on the paper. It’s about setting expectations, understanding potential, and laying the groundwork for effective preparation. By emphasizing the importance of this initial experience, I aim to foster a more informed, realistic approach to standardized testing that ensures the progress students make is both measurable and meaningful.

At Elite Test Prep, I’m not just in the business of improving test scores; I’m in the business of creating informed, experienced learners. Trust in the process, see the value of experience, and let’s transform academic futures, one test at a time.